Hoffa vs The United States
“I cannot agree that what happened in this case is in keeping with the standards of justice in our federal system and I must, therefore, dissent.“
– Chief Justice Earl Warren in Hoffa vs The United States
Only around 50 to 80 court cases out of dozens of thousands a year reach the U.S. Supreme Court. Hoffa versus The United States was on the 1966 supreme court docket, and at the core of their decision was whether or not to use my grandfather’s word to convict Jimmy Hoffa and three of his lieutenants for jury tampering in Chatnooga’s 1962 Test Fleet case. Though Hoffa’s name is on the record, four Teamsters were being tried based on Big Daddy’s word. Hoffa led the charge and therefore what happened to him tells us what happened to the other defendants.
Chief Justice Earl Warren was the only one of nine Supreme Court justices to vote against using my grandfather’s testimony. Hoffa lost his final appeal and immediately began serving an eight year prison sentence; additional charges from a trial in Chicago overlaid, and his total sentence was for eleven years (though the Chicago trial would be overruled in Hoffa’s perpetual battle against his convictions). The other teamsters under Hoffa’s umbrella were sentenced to much shorter terms; though Hoffa had not actually done anything, only his lieutenants had, he was obviously the target of the U.S. Justice System’s multi-year, multi-million dollar, 500 federal agent focus on getting Hoffa.
Hoffa versus The United States is, to this day, still taught in every law school in America; though most students impersonally refer to the people involved as “the defendant” and “the witness.” This is what happened.
Big Daddy, and using his testimony as “the witness,” was so controversial that supreme court justices cited his name 144 times across 22 pages in their analysis of Hoffa versus The United States, more than even Hoffa himself. To see why, it’s useful to start at the 1964 case where Big Daddy stood up as the prosecution’s surprise witness, and to do that it’s best to start with when Big Daddy was in jail and first agreed to be a mole in Hoffa’s inner circle.
In 1962, my grandfather spent two nights in jail and was facing life in prison. Separate charges piled on top of him for kidnapping, manslaughter, and embezzlement. He knew more were coming.
The manslaughter charge was for killing a soldier in Alabama. The soldier’s name and their branch of service was never identified, but there’s no doubt that Big Daddy hit a pedestrian and fled the scene with obvious damage to his car. According to Doug’s autobiography, Big Daddy arrived in Baton Rouge and they tasked a Teamster to have the car fixed. He was arrested for some minor traffic violation while driving the car, and police traced it back to Alabama and the scraped paint matched what was found with the dead soldier. Alabama police issued a cross-state alert and discovered Big Daddy in a Baton Rouge jail and filed manslaughter charges; it was obvious that fleeing the scene of a crime and obstructing justice by hiding evidence would follow. He was guilty and there was irrefutable evidence.
Embezzlement charges were tossed in probably because there was always embezzlement with so much cash floating around Teamsters halls; and with Doug and the car’s driver arrested, prosecutors knew someone would testify against Big Daddy.
The kidnapping charges were for the two month old daughter and six year old son of 22 year old Baton Rouge Teamster Sydney Simpson. He was at the end of a contentious divorce and lost his children in custody court. Big Daddy lent him another one of his cars (he had several), gave him a stack of cash from the Local #5 safe, and asked a few burly Teamsters who acted as his muscle to keep the police away from Simpson’s children until they could find another plan. Big Daddy and Simpson were arrested and placed in a cell together and charged with kidnapping; police issued warrants for the other Teamsters, and everyone knew that if those men were facing a decade in prison they’d squeal on Big Daddy for as many crimes as necessary for prosecutors to give them a deal.
There was no doubt Big Daddy would end up in prison for life. As Doug wrote, ever since he was a teenager my grandfather looked out for himself first. Chief Justice Earl Warren agreed.
Warren wrote:
One Sydney Simpson, who was Partin’s cellmate at the time the latter first contacted federal agents to discuss Hoffa, has testified by affidavit as follows:
“Sometime in September, 1962, I was transferred from the Donaldsonville Parish Jail to the Baton Rouge Parish Jail. I was placed in a cell with Partin. For the first few days, Partin acted sort of brave. Then when it was clear that he was not going to get out in a hurry, he became more excited and nervous. After I had been in the same cell with Partin for about three days, Partin said, ‘I know a way to get out of here. They want Hoffa more than they want me.’ Partin told me that he was going to get one of the deputies to get Bill Daniels. Bill Daniels is an officer in the State of Louisiana. Partin said he wanted to talk to Daniels about Hoffa. Partin said that he was going to talk to Captain Edwards and ask him to get Daniels. A deputy, whose name is not known to me, came and took Partin from the cell. Partin remained away for several hours.“
“A few days later Partin was released from the jail. From the day when I first saw the deputy, until the date when Partin was released, Partin was out of the cell most of the day and sometimes part of the night. On one occasion Partin returned to the cell and said, ‘It will take a few more days and we will have things straightened out, but don’t worry.’ Partin was taken in and out of the cell frequently each day. Partin told me during this time that he was working with Daniels and the FBI to frame Hoffa. On one occasion I asked Partin if he knew enough about Hoffa to be of any help to Daniels and the FBI, and Partin said, ‘It doesn’t make any difference. If I don’t know it, I can fix it up.’
“While we were in the cell, I asked Partin why he was doing this to Hoffa. Partin replied: ‘What difference does it make? I’m thinking about myself. Aren’t you thinking about yourself? I don’t give a damn about Hoffa. . . .”
So Big Daddy made a phone call to the New Orleans FBI director and within 48 hours FBI director J. Edgar Hoover and U.S. Attorney General Bobby Kennedy set him free. Bobby flew to Baton Rouge and individually met with Big Daddy, Doug, Grandma Foster, and Mamma Jean and decided to use Big Daddy as a secret weapon against Hoffa. Big Daddy was free; just like he knew his Teamsters would testify against him in exchange for their freedom, he agreed to spy on Hoffa and report “something” or “anything” that could convict him; that phrasing would become critical in Hoffa versus The United States.
The Cuban Missile Crisis began and Bobby disappeared for two weeks. Big Daddy called Hoffa and asked to meet and discuss his Baton Rouge legal challenges. Hoffa said he could come up to Nashville, where Hoffa had set up a temporary Teamsters headquarters while he defended himself in the Test Fleet case. The Test Fleet was a Detroit trucking company owned on paper by Hoffa’s wife, and because Hoffa was president of an international trucker’s union The Test Fleet was a conflict of interest that violated relatively recent labor laws.
Big Daddy met Walter Sheridan in Nashville, and because he wore tightly tailored suits Walter could not conceal the wireless bugging device on him. It was about as big as “a king size pack of cigarettes,” and Big Daddy did not smoke back then. Without a recording device, Big Daddy reported what he saw and heard in Hoffa’s camp to Walter, who took diligent notes every day.
Big Daddy said Hoffa looked him in the eye and tapped a stack of cash in his pocket and said $20,000 should be enough for one of them, implying Big Daddy could help. Big Daddy also said Hoffa implied other jurors had been reached and the trial should be no problem. Based on what he said, Bobby, Hoover, and Walter believed they could convict Hoffa of jury tampering. Obstruction of justice was a federal offense, greater than anything the Test Fleet case charged.
The Test Fleet jury voted that Hoffa was not guilty. Bobby put the Cuban Missile Crisis behind him and returned his focus to Jimmy Hoffa. He assembled a team of federal attorneys to review what Big Daddy said and how they placed him in Hoffa’s camp, and they agreed there was a strong chance they could win a case for obstruction of justice. Bobby had Hoff in his sites and pulled the trigger.
In 1964 Hoffa was on trial in Chattanooga for obstructing justice in the 1962 Test Fleet case. Prosecutors seemed to know all of his defense plans and details about the 1962 case that no one should know. He became convinced Bobby and Hoover were using electronic bugging devices, so Hoffa hired the most technologically advanced anti-bugging talent he could find, and began trying to monitor the FBI to find evidence of their bugging. He pulled his inner circle tighter, and specified that Big Daddy was to be trusted. Hoffa tossed at least a million dollars at his team of nine attorneys and the mafia’s most sought after electronic surveillance and counter-surveillance experts, who checked his hotel room and also monitored the swarms of federal agents crawling around Chattanooga pretending to be tourists.
When my grandfather walked in as the surprise witness, Hoffa exclaimed “My God, it’s Partin!” The jury found Hoffa guilty of obstructing justice by influencing a jury, and the judge sentenced him to eight years in prison. Federal agents were waiting to start protecting Big Daddy from that moment forward.
Hoffa’s nine attorneys filed appeals based on violations of the 4th and 6th amendments, which is how Hoffa versus The United States reached the supreme court. Though Warren spent most of his summary railing on Big Daddy’s character, that was mostly to emphasize a point and had less to do with the supreme court’s role in either defending or defining the U.S. Constitution and the amendments that make up our Bill of Rights. Most of Hoffa’s defense was based on the 4th Amendment.
The 4th Amendment was penned with quill and ink by our founding fathers in the 1700’s and ratified in 1784, and they evoked a 1600’s British case that led to a then-revolutionary concept that a person should feel safe from government intrusion in their home. The 4th Amendment is a single sentence that says:
The right of the people to be secure in their persons, houses, papers, and effects, against unreasonable searches and seizures, shall not be violated, and no Warrants shall issue, but upon probable cause, supported by Oath or affirmation, and particularly describing the place to be searched, and the persons or things to be seized.
That single sentence was Jimmy Hoffa’s strongest shield against Big Daddy’s testimony: he was tasked to find “something” or “anything” rather than “particularly” describing the place to be searched and the persons or things to be seized.
All of the justices agreed that the 4th amendment’s right to be secure against unreasonable searches and seizures “in their persons, houses, papers, and effects” included hotel rooms. And they agreed that seizure doesn’t apply just to tangible objects, but also to the words someone says when they assume they are speaking privately. Justices deciding Hoffa versus The United States cited previous supreme court cases so that they wouldn’t have to debate that again, and could therefore focus specifically on Big Daddy’s testimony.
Justice Stewart wrote:
A hotel room can clearly be the object of Fourth Amendment protection as much as a home or an office. United States v. Jeffers, 342 U.S. 48. The Fourth Amendment can certainly be violated by guileful as well as by forcible intrusions into a constitutionally protected area. Gouled v. United States, 255 U. S. 298. And the protections of the Fourth Amendment are surely not limited to tangibles, but can extend as well to oral statements. Silverman v. United States, 365 U. S. 505.
Stewart then argued that using Big Daddy’s word did not violate the 4th Amendment because:
When Hoffa made incriminating statements to or in the presence of Partin, his invitee, he relied, not on the security of the hotel room, but on his misplaced confidence that Partin would not reveal his wrongdoing.
Stewart’s lengthy response kept focusing on Big Daddy being invited into the hotel, not sneaking in. Three other justices made similar statements and two abstained. Justice Clark and Justice Douglas, in a somewhat lazy approach that combined their statements (though not as lazy as the two who abstained), simply pointed to judge’s statement from the original trial without reviewing the evidence.
Clark and Douglas wrote:
My examination of the record reveals that at the hearing on petitioners’ motion to suppress the evidence obtained by the informer, Partin, the District Judge found that “the government did not place this witness Mr. Partin in the defendants’ midst . . . rather that he was knowingly and voluntarily placed in their midst by one of the defendants [Hoffa].
They made a jump in logic that I don’t understand; his support of “one of the defendants [Hoffa]” knowingly and voluntarily placing Big Daddy in their midst was also reported only by Big Daddy. They said:
“At one point the informer, Partin, testified: “Mr. Hoffa is the one told me he wanted me to stick around.”
In other words, they asked the wolf if he intended to eat the sheep, and when the wolf said no they believed him.
Warren, whose background was in criminal law, unlike the other forms of law his fellow justices had specialized in, disagreed with their view because it was not based on facts of the case. He pointed to some of the telephone recordings that had been bugged when Big Daddy called Hoffa to set up a meeting. Warren showed how Big Daddy, on behalf of Bobby and Hoover, invited himself into Hoffa’s camp.
Warren wrote:
“Again on a pretext of wanting to talk with Hoffa regarding Partin’s legal difficulties, Partin telephoned Hoffa a few weeks later and succeeded in making a date to meet in Nashville where Hoffa and his attorneys were then preparing for the Test Fleet trial. Unknown to Hoffa, this call was also recorded and again federal authorities were informed as to the details.“
And:
“[The government] employed him not for the purpose of testifying to something that had already happened, but rather for the purpose of infiltration to see if crimes would in the future be committed.”
And:
Pursuant to the general instructions he received from federal authorities to report “any attempts at witness intimidation or tampering with the jury,” “anything illegal,” or even “anything of interest,” Partin became the equivalent of a bugging device which moved with Hoffa wherever he went. Everything Partin saw or heard was reported to federal authorities and much of it was ultimately the subject matter of his testimony in this case.
Warren kept emphasizing that Big Daddy was manipulated into Hoffa’s camp after he made a deal, and he was asked to find “anything illegal” or “anything of interest,” which was an unequivocal violation of the 4th amendment’s specificity requirement. He said it in as many different ways as possible, as if confused that the obviousness of the violation was not being heard by his fellow justices.
He spoke of his fellow justices’s laziness in a politically correct form when he wrote:
I cannot agree either with the opinion of the Court affirming these convictions or with the separate opinions of MR. JUSTICE CLARK and MR. JUSTICE DOUGLAS to the effect that the writs of certiorari were improvidently granted.
(“Writs of certiorari” is Latin for “to be more fully informed,” and is used by higher courts to gain full access to the decision process of lower courts; “improvidently,” according to my dictionary, means “not showing foresight; being unwise when planning for the future.”)
Warren continued to show how in accepting the lower court’s decision blindly, Clark and Douglas were also guilty of acting improvidently, and that it is the explicit job of the supreme court to be more conscientious than lower courts. He wrote:
As to the latter, it seems to me that the finding of the District Court which so troubles my Brothers CLARK and DOUGLAS is in fact no roadblock to our review of the important questions presented by the petitions. It has long been settled that this Court will not be bound by the findings of lower courts when it is alleged that fundamental constitutional rights have been violated. Jacobellis v. Ohio, 378 U. S. 184 (1964); Haynes v. Washington, 373 U. S. 503 (1963); Watts v. Indiana, 338 U. S. 49 (1949); Hooven & Allison Co. v. Evatt, 324 U. S. 652 (1945); Norris v. Alabama, 294 U. S. 587 (1935). We have said, “The duty of this Court to make its own independent examination of the record when federal constitutional deprivations are alleged is clear, resting, as it does, on our solemn responsibility for maintaining the Constitution inviolate.” Napue v. Illinois, 360 U. S. 264, 271 (1959).
To show that his colleagues were not looking at facts when they said my grandfather was only incidentally in Hoffa’s camp on invitation, Warren re-emphasized how Big Daddy became an informant:
“… a brief summary discloses that Partin, after discussing Hoffa with federal agents and learning of their intense and mutually beneficial interest, successfully solicited an invitation to meet with Hoffa. Partin’s release from jail was assisted by the federal agents, and he was compensated in a financial sense as well; in return, he kept the federal agents fully informed of all that occurred from the outset of his contact with Hoffa.”
Warren goes on and on for several pages. He bluntly said that Hoffa versus The United should not have reached the supreme court based on a review of the evidence; he stopped short of criticizing the lower courts, though he was comfortable chastising Stewart and Clark for not showing foresight and being unwise when planning for the future consequences of allowing the 4th Amendment to be assailed in the pursuit of one person; because America uses a predicate based legal system, a weakened 4th Amendment would have long-term consequences for the future of American justice; a weakened Bill of rights creates would solve one day’s problems, but would create a slippery slope and build momentum over time.
Despite his clear belief in the unconstitutionality of using any witness with the same facts, Warren couldn’t seem to help attacking my grandfather’s character again and again. He agrees that disreputable witnesses are often necessary to fight crime, and that, logically, informants and police do not advertise themselves; Warren had voted to allow the testimony of disreputable witnesses in two other cases that day, but those cases followed the constitution and had many differences in the witnesses’s incentives. To explain, Warren cites Mamma Jean:
For his services he was well paid by the Government, both through devious and secret support payments to his wife and, it may be inferred, by executed promises not to pursue the indictments under which he was charged at the time he became an informer.
Warren criticizes prosecutors of paying for testimony; the Partin family became a noteworthy case separate from Hoffa simply because it was so rare to pay people to testify, a form of bribery ironic in a case involving influencing justice by bribing a jury. In other words, there’s a conflict of interest when you are paid to say something.
And it wasn’t just cash. Big Daddy also thrived on the fame, and unlike the more known type of informant who is hidden from retribution, the Partin family was showcased in national media and Big Daddy used his fame to springboard his power in Louisiana. And it was impunity: he was free to do as he pleased as long as Hoffa was in prison. Warren emphasized that Bobby’s long arms reached out across the country to grant Big Daddy not just clemency for a crime committed with Hoffa, but for practically any crime, any where, and across time. That freedom was worth more than petty cash.
Warren emphasized Big Daddy’s incentives:
In the four years since [Partin] first volunteered to be a against Hoffa he has not been prosecuted on any of the serious federal charges for which he was at that time jailed, and the state charges have apparently vanished into thin air.
All of that debate in America’s highest court of law was just for the single sentence 4th Amendment. Hoffa’s attorneys also said Big Daddy’s testimony violated the 6th Amendment.
The 6th Amendment is lengthy and peppered with legalese, but it distills down to a defendant’s right to have attorney’s present when questioned, and the right to face a witness’s claims. At the heart of Hoffa’s claim that his 6th Amendment rights were violated was Big Daddy listening to his defense planning with attorney’s during the Test Fleet, and that nuances in phrasing were summarized by Big Daddy and used by prosecutors without Hoffa’s attorneys present to watch for incriminating statements taken out of context. For me, someone who knew Big Daddy, I also see the 6th Amendment as a way to protect people like Hoffa from people like Big Daddy, who are so charming that they could get anyone to loosen their tongue and say something they may not have said otherwise. And attorneys can caution a client to not say things that could be used against him.
The other justices admitted how much access Big Daddy had to Hoffa’s statements when they said:
“Petitioners’ own witnesses testified that Partin was in the suite “virtually every day” as well as the “nightly meetings,” had “ready access” to the files and offices and acted as “sergeant-at-arms” just outside the door of the suite.”
And yet again they relied not on judicial insight or conscientiousness, but on Big Daddy’s word as the wolf among sheep. They said:
[Partin] said he might have heard some of the lawyers’ conversations, but he didn’t know what they were talking about, “because I wasn’t interested in what they had to say about the case.” He testified that he did not report any of the lawyers’ conversations to Sheridan, because the latter “wasn’t interested in what the attorneys said.” Partin’s testimony was largely confirmed by Sheridan.
Sheridan did testify, however, to one occasion when Partin told him about a group of prospective character witnesses being interviewed in the suite by one of the petitioner’s lawyers, who “was going over” some written “questions and answers” with them. This information was evidently relayed by Sheridan to the chief government attorney at the Test Fleet trial.
I’m not a lawyer, much less a supreme court justice, but I’ve always believe using Big Daddy’s word violated both the 4th and the 6th amendments. That doesn’t mean he lied in his testimony; to Warren’s point, the supreme court should focus on defending the constitution, not judging a witness’s character or a jury’s decision. After all, because of America’s predicate-based system, allowing a “walking bugging device” tasked with finding “anything illegal” or “something of interest” without a warrant sets the precedent for prosecutors to bypass the weakened U.S. constitution’s Bill of Rights in perpetuity, or at least until congress acts again.1
Despite millions of dollars spent on defense attorneys, Hoffa went to prison immediately after Warren was the only dissenting judge in 1966’s Hoffa versus the United States based solely on, as Warren said, my grandfather’s word.
The ghost of Big Daddy’s testimony persists to this day, decades after Hoffa vanished and Big Daddy died, because lower courts can use supreme court cases after a supreme court case is decided. From 1966’s Hoffa versus The United States until today, the phrasing of finding “anything” and a “walking bugging device” persist in America’s legal system, and that’s one of the reasons Hoffa versus The United States is still studied – at least ostensibly – in law schools. No one knows how many people went to prison because of how allowing Big Daddy’s testimony removed teeth from our founding father’s succinct 4th Amendment against unreasonable search and seizure.
Not even Warren, whose prescience cautioned against the “slippery slope” of the government using a “walking bugging device” to find “anything illegal,” foresaw the future of computers when he wrote those words in 1966. In his day, Walter took hand-written notes on what a walking bugging device said he saw or overheard, then collected other evidence and made a case; today, computers can analyze hundreds of millions of conversations and human interactions every minute.
One of the most poignant uses of Hoffa versus The United States was at the heart of President George W. Bush’s controversial 2001 PATRIOT Act that allowed unwarranted monitoring of all American cell phone conversations and text messages using a massive computer system looking for anything of interest.
The PATRIOT Act was so controversial that it, plus a few other things like inflation and a struggling economy, led Bush to have some of the lowest approval ratings in history. Because of that, Bush focused more than two chapters of his memoir, Decision Points, on the PATRIOT Act, which has it’s roots in Hoffa versus The United States.
The backronym stands for Uniting and Strengthening America by “Providing Appropriate Tools Required to Intercept and Obstruct Terrorism” Act of 2001. It immediately followed September 11th, 2001, and the coordinated hijacking of passenger airliners that crashed into and destroyed World Trade Center’s two towering skyscrapers in New York, and crashed into the military’s pentagon in Washington DC, and, because of passenger resistance, crashed into a Pennsylvania field rather than other buildings; thousands of people died that day, and Bush wanted to act quickly and decisively to stop it from happening again. One of his decision points was using the weakened 4th Amendment to search practically every phone message in America.
Bush Junior, like even the most junior of attorneys, knew the simplicity of the founding father’s 4th Amendment wouldn’t allow unwarranted surveillance, so he tasked his Attorney General, John Ashcroft, to find a legal loophole that allowed computers to monitor everyone and look for anything of interest. Hoffa versus The United States became a cornerstone of The PATRIOT Act.
In one of the most ironic coincidences I know – one that I say is funny when laughing with friends around a campfire – is that Ashcroft tasked assistant attorney Jack Goldsmith to lead the PATRIOT Act’s justification, Jack is the stepson of Chuckie O’Brien, Hoffa’s short and stout pitbull of what people said was his adopted son but was, technically, a mentee. He was the one at Hoffa’s Chatanooga trial that lept over surprised security guards and pummeled a gunman with his own pistol before being pried off, and would say on his deathbed: “Fucking Partin! I should have killed him when I had the chance.” Jack and I still laugh about that.
There was an army of attorneys helping, but Jack was the filter between them and Bush. He admitted he was shocked when he reviewed the suggested predicates and saw Hoffa versus The United States and another, similar case involving Chuckie. Like most people who read the evidence would agree with Chief Justice Earl Warren that the writs of certiorari were improvidently granted in Hoffa versus The United States, but that regardless of hindsight review that decision stood firm.
Jack completed his work for Ashcroft, then resigned based on what he believed were ethical violations; just because you can legally justify something doesn’t make it right. Jack became faculty at Harvard and reconnected with his estranged stepfather and began writing a memoir about that connection: “In Hoffa’s Shadow: A Stepfather, a Disappearance in Detroit, and My Search for the Truth.”
In Hoff’a Shadow was coincidentally published within a month of Wendy dying and just before The Irishman film was released, and he detailed his resistance to the PATRIOT Act but mostly focused on exonerating Chuckie from the persistent claims, including those of The Irishman, that Chuckie was involved in killing Hoffa. In his memoir, he also discusses how, because he was Chuckie’s stepson (and adopted son, because Chuckie and Jack’s mom completed that process), the FBI had his name flagged as a person of interest in Hoffa’s death decades later; when he was under review for his security clearance to be an assistant general attorney in the late 1990’s, his clearance was delayed because agents saw the flag that he had intimate knowledge of Chuckie and therefore may have heard something yet undocumented. Jack was unaware that just before his book was published, my great-uncle Doug self published “From My Brother’s Shadow: Teamster Douglas Westley Partin Finally Tells His Side of The Story.”
In another coincidence, Jack and I shared a membership in that small club of being on an FBI’s watchlist because of our family’s involvement with Hoffa; my 1993 security clearance and diplomatic passport under President Clinton was also delayed because I was Edward Partin’s grandson and with him the year he died and spoke with Walter about it at Big Daddy’s 1990 funeral. When Jack and I spoke about his memoir and laughed about our overlap in the 90’s, I joked that I was not a lawyer, but it seemed that Jack was the world’s second most informed expert on Hoffa versus The United States and the U.S. Constitution’s 4th Amendment. He didn’t seem to get the joke.
In addition to stepping over the barely breathing 4th Amendment, part of Bush Junior’s PATRIOT Act also paved the way for arresting suspects and imprisoning them without an attorney or a trial in Cuba’s Guantanamo Bay. For confusing reasons in international law, America has maintained a navy base on Cuban soil since around 1900 after attempts to overthrow or control Cuba during the Spanish-American war (if anything, America has been persistent and consistent in how we treat Cuba). America maintained Guantanamo Bay or generations even during the Cuban Missile Crisis and Cuban embargo, and in 2002 President Bush Junior authorized using it as a prison unprotected by the U.S. Constitution’s Bill of Rights.
The argument is that Guantanamo Bay is not on American soil, therefore not subject to the U.S. Constitution. Bush Junior’s advisors said: “a federal district court could not properly exercise habeas jurisdiction over an alien detained at [Guantanamo Bay, Cuba]” In other words, the founding father’s claim that “all men are created equal” didn’t originally apply to women or African Americans, and that after decades of fighting that battle the U.S. Constitution is not a right of humans, it’s a right only on soil we claim is part of the United States of America.
Guantanamo prisoners receive neither an attorney nor a speedy trial as promised in the Bill of Rights. And military guards at Guantanamo guards, believing they were following orders or intentions, tortured the prisoners in what became an internationally contested incident yet to be resolved. Prisoners were starved, kept in dark isolation, water-boarded (their faces covered in towels and drenched with water so they felt they were drowning again and again and again), repeatedly told their families were dead or threatened, and smothered with women’s panties stained with menstrual blood. Bush profusely apologizes for the torture his memoir; but to this day, more than a quarter of a century later, some of those prisoners still languish in their Cuban jail cells under what is mostly solitary confinement, and no amount of international pressure has been able to redirect the momentum that put them there. It’s reminiscent of even Justice Earl Warren’s support during World War II of imprisoning 250,000 Japanese American’s on American soil without an attorney or trial, but with torture added and with the entire world trying to halt the slippery slope created by a few hastily decided court cases.
It may take a revision of the constitution to kibosh what was started before I was born; without realizing it, America’s surveillance practices are still in the shadow of Big Daddy and the pursuit of Jimmy Hoffa.
Bush Junior’s act also steered massive amounts of federal funding into what became The Department of Homeland Security, an ambiguous organization that outweighs funding to all other arms of justice and law enforcement combined. President Trump inherited that department, and his administration built upon the PATRIOT Act and its weak foundation of Hoffa versus The United States to allow minimally trained, masked ICE agents who had been recruited by software targeting extremist watching Youtube channels for right-wing ideology and mixed martial arts and then armed with weapons that – I can attest to – would make special operatives shocked at their lethal firepower directed at civilians; those agents were allowed to violate the 4th Amendment by asking people on the street simple questions like “where are you from” and then arresting and deporting them without an attorney or trial.
ICE, the agency formed after September 11th to remove illegal immigrants from American soil, was eventually allowed to racially profile. Racial profiling was deemed illegal decades ago in response to police disproportionately targeting African Americans, but a new court of president-appointed justices overrode previous justice and said that profiling is exactly how you spot illegal immigrants. In my mind’s sense of gallows humor, I now see Big Daddy’s aryan good looks as his best defense for staying out of jail. And if prison is anything like what Jimmy Hoffa reported or what I saw on news about Guantanamo Bay, it’s no wonder my grandfather did whatever he could to stay out; as Warren wrote, Big Daddy was incentivized to testify against Hoffa.
It turns out that Hoffa was guilty. And it wasn’t just Big Daddy’s word, his word was just the final nail in Hoffa’s coffin. Mostly it was what he said collaborated with so much insight into the juror’s personal lives and contacts made with them before Hoffa’s trial that it was obvious someone was behind the scenes and pulling strings. Decades later, a few other people, including Chuckie, finally admitted that they had, despite swearing otherwise, helped Hoffa rig not just the Test Fleet jury, but many others during Bobby’s bombardment of charges against Hoffa in Blood Feud. The Irishman said that was simply pride and caution: ironically, Hoffa didn’t want any of Bobby’s tricks to pop up and surprise him, and therefore he shot himself and gave Bobby the final nail to put in his coffin.
But, to Warren’s repeated points, Hoffa versus The United States was never about whether Hoffa was or was not guilty, or even about my grandfather’s character (despite Warrens assailing it). His main argument was that the U.S. Constitution specifies a process of justice that, once weakened, creates a slippery slope that sometimes takes generations to gain enough momentum to impact daily life. I don’t know what Warren would say if he were alive today and looked back at the prescience of his words in light of the PATRIOT Act, Guantanamo Bay, and ICE agents.
Warren died in 1974, long before computers and remote sensing devices had shrunk from a king size pack of cigarettes to tiny dots that look like decoration on eyeglasses; three years after Hoffa was freed by Nixon; and one year before Hoffa vanished and was probably killed. Warren’s posthumously published memoirs don’t mention Hoffa versus The United States at all; mostly he focuses on cases like Roe versus Wade, Brown vs. The Board of Education, and the case that gave us The Miranda Rights (the right to remain silent, and the 6th Amendment right to an attorney). Some of those decisions have been reversed, but it’s possible that too much momentum has gathered behind enhanced surveillance for that to change without a focused effort from society.
These were the things I knew and believed when I flew from San Diego to Baton Rouge to be by Wendy Partin’s side as she died. My mind swirled with memories of my father, Big Daddy, and Wendy’s struggle as a 16 year old girl who didn’t know the slippery slope she stood on when she first spoke with Edward Grady Partin Junior.
But in her final hours all I could think about was being present with her while I could. In the months that followed her death, I kept thinking back to when she met my dad in 1971 and knew nothing about how Ed Partin would become such a big part in history. In my heart, and as a selfish person, the impact of Hoffa versus The United States on my life and the life of my 16 year old mother shouts more loudly than the tormented screams of thousands of prisoners since the supreme court allowed my grandfather’s word to convict Jimmy Hoffa.
In 1966 Hoffa didn’t know his conviction would lead to decades of weakening civil rights, he just wanted to get out of jail. To do that, he had to either get my grandfather to change his testimony, which would mean he would have to admit to perjuring and probably serve prison for that, or to testify that Bobby and Hoover had used illegal wire tapping to monitor Hoffa’s defense and thereby have the entire case thrown out. Hoffa spent the next few years in his maximum security penitentiary cell thinking of practically nothing else.
Hoffa would use all of his resources to get out of prison. He tapped two unlikely sources, America’s most decorated war hero, Audie Murphy, and the 1971 presidential candidate Richard Nixon, who would be elected and commute Hoffa’s sentence only a week before I was conceived by Edward Partin Junior. Ironically, Nixon would resign in 1975, the same year Hoffa vanished, for authorizing illegal wire tapping and obstructing justice. That part in the story is next.
Go to the Table of Contents

- In the months following the terrorist airline hijackings that took down New York’s twin towers of the World Trade center and almost took out Washington DC’s pentagon, President George Bush Junior and attorney general John Ashcroft’s team of attorneys cited my grandfather’s testimony in Hoffa versus The United States that allowed him to be “the equivalent of a walking bugging device” tasked to find “anything illegal” or “something of interest” against Hoffa as the foundation of 2001’s PATRIOT Act that allowed the unwarranted monitoring of hundreds of millions of Americans’s cell phones calls and text messages for “something” or “anything” about plots against the government.
And in 2025, President Trump’s administration would build upon that to allow dozens of thousands of ICE agents, an three-letter agency that had grown exponentially since budget shifting after the PATRIOT Act, to listen to anyone and immediately arrest, detain, and deport people from American soil. Part of the PATRIOT Act would also be used to detain and torture suspects in Cuba’s American-controlled Guantanamo Bay without warrants, an attorney, or a trial.
All stemmed from my grandfather’s testimony being allowed in Hoffa versus The United States, which cited a few other predicate cases, but the key to Big Daddy’s testimony were the words “anything” rather than specifying what to search and seize, including words and presumed intentions. ↩︎
